AFL/Offseason Update: Oct. 20, 2025
Half of you may not see this post, thanks to the current AWS outage, but I’ll post what I can now and update later…
Scottsdale was winning won 15-4 in the 8th eight innings and appears en route to for its fourth straight win.
Jake Bennett, however, was responsible for three of those runs over his three innings of work. He gave up five hits, four in the 3rd after sitting through the Scorpions’ 12-run rally, walked none, and struck out four. He threw 61 pitches, 38 for strikes.
Austin Amaral was the first man out of the Scottsdale ‘pen and set the side down in order twice, striking out three. Barring another 12-run rally, he’s in line to pick up the win. He was credit with the win, his first of the fall.
Sam Petersen was the sole National in the starting lineup. He batted 9th and drove in four with a two-run single and a two-run double, but struck out twice. Petersen fielded two hits and had two putouts.
Scottsdale returns to action tomorrow with a doubleheader in Peoria.
Now, if you’ll excuse me, I heard they have AWS over on Maple street…
Season Review: The 2025 FCL Nationals
With the FCL now fulfilling the role that was previously played by short-season “A”*(acclimation to playing stateside), the focus here can be on the DSL grads. Don’t believe me? Do a sort by PA on the 2025 FCL batters and see for yourself.
* I still think MLB should have renamed the classifications below AA as A, B, C & D so we could be rid of the awful “single-A” used by lazy and/or dumb writers
Five of the top 10 batters by usage were in the DSL in 2024. Four were repeating the level. The tenth was Sir Jamison Jones, a 15th Rd. HS pick from the ’24 Draft. The good news is that the ’24 DSL grads progressed at the next level. The bad news is that only one of the ’24 FCL repeaters did the same.
It’s a different story with the pitchers. Just two ’24 DSLers were sent stateside, though they were 1-2 in IP. Five repeated the level, but only saw more usage (Brayan Romero, who spent most of ’25 in Low-A). Three of the top seven pitchers by IP coming off an injury-shortened ’24.
Despite that, the Nats were pitchers were only slightly older than the league average (21.3 vs. 20.9), as the Nats were not alone in using the complex leagues for rehabs.
Still, with a group of league-average batters that were 4th in the FCL at 4.98 R/G and the #4 pitching staff (4.27 R/G) the ’25 F-Nats finished 2nd in the FCL East, eight games behind their co-tenants, but with their first winning record since 2022. As you might expect with a fair amount of teenagers, the team was below-average on defense, aside from throwing out runners (34%, 2nd best).
And now, the obligatory Top 5’s
| TOP 5 BATS | TOP 5 ARMS |
| 1. Sir Jamison Jones, C .266 GPA, .379 OBP, 26 BB in 40G |
1. Jose Feliz, RHSP 2.20/3.01/1.13, 1.8 BB/9IP in 14G(13GS) |
| 2. Luis Arias, 3B .264 GPA, .293 BA, 14E in 34G |
2. Luke Johnson, RHRP 1.23/2.99/1.09, 0HR in 36⅔ IP |
| 3. Angel Feliz, SS .254 GPA, 12XBH, 30BB in 53G |
3. Tommy Kane, LHRP 2.92/3.00/1.25, 12.4 K/9IP in 24⅔ IP |
| 4. Dashyll Tejeda, RF .250 GPA, 29SB in 41G |
4. Liam Sullivan, LHSP 1.35/3.02/1.05, 12.6 K/9IP, 5.9BB/9IP in 20IP |
| 5. Eyeksson Rojas, 2B .232 GPA, 25K, 25RBI in 41G |
5. Darrel Lunar, RHSP 4.93/4.20/1.60, 9.3 K/9IP, 4HBP, 5BK in 45⅔ IP |
The aforemntioned 10 were the only ones who surpassed 100PA, though it should be noted that there were a couple of older/’24 draft picks were pushed up fairly quickly after making their pro debuts (e.g., Sam Petersen, Luke Dickerson), that in the old world order may have gotten to 100PA in their first pro season.
Folks interested in seeing the full teams stats can find them here. FIP data can be found here.
Luke, fully agreed that it was a huge missed opportunity to get rid of the ridiculousness of having 2 entirely distinct leagues share the moniker of “A ball” with a weird “A” and “A+” distinction (shouldn’t we at least call the Carolina League “A-” ball?). The simplest solution would’ve been to just shift everything up a level, and arrive at AAAA, but a grading A-F would’ve been better than the status quo.
The FCL team is such a strange one. There were so few players who had actually “good” seasons, and yet the team overall was very good. It also doesn’t help that the quality of the FCL is so, so bad that Andy Acevedo’s putrid line of .188/.378/.212 was only a smidgen below league average (94 wRC+). Contrast this with the hitter-friendly IL, where Jalen Battles, a minor leaguer for the Rays posted a similar line of .240/.328/.260, which was worth a mere 63 wRC+ in the IL.
Jose Feliz is the clear POTY for the FCL, and basically the only arm of note at all. Johnson, Kane, Sullivan and Romero were each 23, welllll above league average. Kane and Johnson’s struggles with their promotions also indicate they might have just been dominating much younger, less-developed players than an indication of real talent. But let’s see. Sullivan did well in Fredericksburg, and will need a very aggressive promotion schedule next year.
Let’s start with the good news: in 11 AFL innings, Jake Bennett has struck out 17 and walked only two! He must be awesome! We’ll just leave out the minor inconvenience of 11 hits and 8 earned runs. (Sigh.) He’s a lock to be added to the 40-man ahead of Rule 5, but his AZ experience isn’t exactly confirming his fine regular season. At least the Ks are a plus after only punching out 6.5 per 9 at AA.