Sickels Releases Top 20 Nats Prospect List
This morning John Sickels released his Washington Nationals Top 20 list. Here’s a look at how it breaks down by letter grade:
| A | Lucas Giolito |
| B+ | Michael Taylor, A.J. Cole |
| B | Trea Turner, Joe Ross |
| B- | Wilmer Difo, Erick Fedde, Reynaldo Lopez, Drew Ward |
| C+ | Brian Goodwin, Austin Voth, Rafael Bautista, Jakson Reetz, Felipe Rivero, Pedro Severino, Raudy Read, Spencer Kieboom, Tony Renda, Chris Bostick |
| C | Nick Pivetta |
Let’s revisit my explanation for the layout…
The primary focus here is on letter grades, not numerical rank, which you can get by going top to bottom, then left in each row. Lucas Giolito is #1, Michael Taylor is #2, A.J. Cole is #3… Chris Bostick is #19, Nick Pivetta is #20.
The secondary focus is on improvement by letter grade, which you can see by the color red. Because Sickels only ranks Grade C or better, that means becoming a C+ or better guy after being previously identified as a Grade C.
Top 20 guys from 2014 are in bold while guys that played their way onto the list are in italics. Like last April, I chose not to italicize the players acquired by trade but did indicated if they improved (Joe Ross).
My apologies in advance if I misled anyone with the earlier post; I was unaware that Nick Melotte and Sickels were both doing Top 20 lists. That said, it is interesting to see, as others have noted, the differences between the two. Sickels is much higher on Goodwin while lower on Lopez. But you should click the link above to see for yourself as Sickels has a comment for each and every one.
Hate to say it, but I think Cole might be overrated given what I’ve read on this site. Looks like the Souza trade was a good one from Sickels perspective. Can’t think that Souza would have been more than a B- on his grades and Turner’s a B. Well done again, Rizzo, and thanks for being the first to share this helpful info. This year I’ll likely be in a position to get the prospects well before Spring Training if I go and get them at a better price. Looking forward to getting back in the prospect groove and can’t wait for some better weather after a necessary time of reflection and preparation for a great spring, summer, and prayerfully Championship(s) Fall!
when you start to feel that way about Cole, take a look at Doug Fister’s minor league stats and try to imagine what those same commenters would have said about him.
I’ve taken the four top National prospect lists that have been on here and gave points to their placement. Overall top nine are unsurprisingly 1. Giolito 2. Taylor 3. Turner 4. Cole 5. Lopez 6. Fedde 7. Ross 8. Difo 9. Ward Number 10 through 13 would come from a group of Reetz, Batista, Voth, and Goodwin. I realize there isn’t much point to this exercise but I find it sort of fun.
Well, one of my questions this winter was: can Travis Henke make AA……. nope…
Kevin Mattison? cuse while Ramsey repeats april in Harrisburg??
anybody notice Strasburg nemisis sign with fish- Tyler Colvin???
no Funky cold Medina @ Hagerstown in 15