NationalsProspects.com

Vote For Your Favorite Bats


Since this is a popular feature — and it’s rather quiet on the minor-league front, unless you’re into start times and hot stove guests — let’s do this again.

For those unfamiliar with the drill (and obviously good at brushing and flossing), send me your Top 10 list of minor-league position players (40-man guys are eligible as long as they have rookie status) to enfieldmass-top10bats[at]yahoo[dot]com (link will open your preferred email client) or submit them in comments.

After I get enough submissions to work with, I’ll update this post to close the polls and weight the lists in reverse order (#1 = 10 points, #2 = 9 points, yada yada yada, #10 = 1 point).

Then, I’ll present the fifth annual NationalsProspects.com Top 10 Bats. Now, bear in mind that I use the term “bat” as a shorthand for a position player. As we all know too well, some folks will make it to the majors despite being poor on defense. Nevertheless, I would like you to consider both offense and defense in your selections, if for no other reason than the National League still does not have the designated hitter [insert troll remark here].

In addition to being an exercise that reinforces our sense of community on this site, I think it also produces a better list than if I were to pick it myself, which I did the first year. While there are some obvious exceptions, this is based on the “Wisdom of Crowds” theory that the collective opinions of many is usually more accurate than the opinion of one, which is an old idea (think Aristotle) that’s been given new life by a 2004 business book by James Surowiecki.

If nothing else, it’ll give us something to discuss until the Winter Meetings begin tomorrow.

UPDATE: I’m calling it and writing the next post.

10 Commments

  1. Struggled after #7…

    Souza
    Taylor
    Difo
    Reetz
    Ward
    Goodwin
    Skole
    Kieboom
    Vettleson
    Kobernus

  2. I agree with Andrew s top ten but I have to
    Insert Wooten ahead of half those guys
    . 15 should show a year in which Estarlin
    Finally hits some home runs and miller time
    Stays healthy. Jeff Gardner could do some nice
    Mashing once the temps warm up in Hagerstown.
    Plus hopefully a couple other guys with him
    Up from auburn

  3. We have all thought which kids Auburn
    / GCL will breAk out on 2015 in conjunction
    With the bats list.
    Read @ Hagerstown another

  4. 1. Taylor
    2. Souza
    3. Ward
    4. Reetz
    5. Difo
    6. Goodwin
    7. Severino
    8. Renda
    9. Bautista
    10. Kieboom
    Honorable Mention: Skole, S. Perez

  5. Missed Bautista and would stick him at 8 before Kieboom on my list (if I’m allowed to change).

  7. 1. Taylor 2. Souza 3. Difo 4. Reetz 5. Severino 6. Goodwin 7. Bautista 8. Ward 9. Kieboom 10. Skole

    1. Good for him, parlaying a .840+ OPS in AAA into a good payday.
      Pretty good for a 27th rounder.

Comments are closed.